Bodies and Souls
Sister Manette working at the health clinic in Jonestown, Mississippi, Bodies and Souls, 2005.
Bodies and Souls illuminates the quiet efforts of Sister Manette Durand, a white Catholic nun running the only health clinic in rural Jonestown, Mississippi. The residents of Jonestown, a largely African American town in the heart of the Delta, share a condition faced by low income, rural Americans struggling to obtain basic medical care. Nearly every family in this town is touched by diabetes and heart disease. Yet many lack the resources to visit a doctor more than once or twice in their entire lives. The video follows Sister Manette through her daily challenge of providing the only health care services this community has seen in the last fifteen years. Despite very limited resources, she keeps a refreshingly practical approach to faith, race, and poverty. Through intimate observational scenes of her with her patients, Bodies and Souls profiles Sister Manette's labors "to help save bodies, so that the souls can come alive."
|Bodies and Souls. A short film by Christie Herring, 2005.|
When the body is falling apart, it's hard to pay attention to what your soul is telling you.
—Sister Manette Durand
Sister Manette with a patient, Bodies and Souls, 2005.
I grew up in Canton, Mississippi—a few hours drive from Jonestown. My first film, Waking in Mississippi (made with Andre Robinson) explored race relations in my hometown. The film delved into the election of the first black mayor in 1994 and the filming of A Time to Kill one year later. The mayoral race ended in threats of a riot. One year later, a race riot was the climactic scene in A Time to Kill, which was filmed entirely on-location in Canton. It wasn't until Bodies and Souls that I returned to Mississippi with a camera.
After making Waking in Mississippi, I moved to Boston where I spent four years working in the Department of Health Policy and Management at the Harvard School of Public Health. One of our primary foci at the time was racial and gender disparities in healthcare. I learned about common barriers to receiving healthcare and the importance of intervention when looking at large-scale results. While my approach to social justice had once been ideological, now it had a practical foundation. And when I returned to filmmaking, it was with an appreciation for the intersection of policy and social change. For my thesis film in graduate school, I decided to return home to Mississippi and approach the topic of rural healthcare.
Jonestown residents and patients of the clinic, Bodies and Souls, 2005.
I knew that I wanted to make a film about rural healthcare, largely explored through observational footage in a clinic, to shed light on the real and daily challenges of keeping the doors open. My initial vision was to follow a clinic providing specialty care to clearly illustrate opportunities for immediate transformation. I thought an AIDS clinic would give me an opportunity to explore issues around race, religion, and sexuality. But as I visited clinic after clinic, I saw that the most prevalent and overwhelming healthcare challenge in the Delta was for primary care. Every clinic I visited was helmed by a Catholic nun or a recent immigrant. These were not places to go to make money. Simply keeping the doors open presented enormous challenges. However, these clinics serve a critical need. Treating the most common chronic conditions such as diabetes, heart disease, and severe arthritis—small rural clinics affected everyday lives.
|A patient has her blood pressure taken at the clinic in Jonestown, Bodies and Souls, 2005.|
Although this film is not strictly observational, the work of Fred Wiseman was a prominent guidepost throughout the process, as it is in much of my work. I studied his films Hospital, Welfare, and Public Housing, each of which consists entirely of observational footage without narration or interviews. While certainly not unmediated, I was drawn to this immersive style for Bodies and Souls. My goal was to allow the viewer an opportunity to feel part of Jonestown, to feel immersed in the fabric of the community, to feel the challenges of life and complexity of relationships in their own way.
In 2006, Mississippi had one of the lowest number of physicians per capita in the nation (177 per 100,000 versus the national average of 267 per 100,000). Mississippi has the highest national level of obesity (32.5%), a condition linked to diabetes, heart disease, and countless other ailments. The Mississippi Delta is at the epicenter of these trends, and Jonestown is located in the heart of the Delta. Between the Yazoo and Mississippi Rivers, this town of 1,600 people, 96% of whom are African American, is a half hour from Clarksdale, a town of twenty thousand. Jonestown has one elementary school and sends its older students to schools in Clarksdale. Of local residents, 50% of adults have not graduated from high school and over 30% do not have access to a car, despite a complete lack of public transportation. Before Sister Manette took on the clinic, there had been no healthcare available in Jonestown for 15 years.
There is no denying the correlation between poverty, and poor health outcomes. The crisis and need in rural areas for intervention is obvious. What are our values as a society if we allow so many people to fall through the cracks? Bodies and Souls follows the work of one woman who has dedicated her life to imparting lasting change on a community, one patient at a time.
Christie Herring received her M.A. in Documentary Film and Video from Stanford University and currently lives in San Francisco where she works in independent film and online media. Herring began making films after graduation from Duke University, when she collaborated with Andre Robinson in producing and directing Waking in Mississippi. This sixty-minute video about race relations in her hometown has been shown across the country, including a special screening at the National Civil Rights Museum in Memphis, Tennessee during the official thirtieth anniversary commemoration of the assassination of Martin Luther King, Jr. In addition to media production, Herring has worked in public health research, anti-violence outreach, and virtual reality gaming. This film was made with support from the Phil Hardin Foundation, the Tom Pollack Foundation, and the Community Foundation of Northwest Mississippi.
Barr, Donald A. Health Disparities in the United States: Social Class, Race, Ethnicity, and Health. Baltimore, Maryland: John Hopkins University Press, 2008.
Committee on Understanding and Eliminating Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care. Unequal Treatment: Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care. Smedley, B.D, A.Y. Stith & A.R. Nelson (eds.) Washington, DC: National Academies Press, 2003.
Herring, Christie. The Campaign. Stanford, California: Department of Communication, Stanford University, 2009.
———. Chickens in the City. Stanford, California: Department of Communication, Stanford University, 2004.
———. Howdy Partner. Stanford, California: Department of Communication, Stanford University, 2003.
To learn more about the filmmaker and her work, please visit her website: http://www.christieherring.com
To purchase a DVD of the film, visit the distributor's website: http://www.fanlight.com/catalog/films/454_bas.php. For home use, please go to the website: http://www.fanlight.com/offers.php and use the offer code BS0454.
Charles Reagan Wilson, "Mississippi Delta," Southern Spaces 4 April 2004
Zipporah Films. "Frederick Wiseman Chronicler of the Western Worlds." 2006.
Jenkins, Derek and Lindsey Millar. "Don't Miss These Movies" Arkansas Times, May 17, 2007.
Sister Manette and Her Community:
Kilborn, Peter T. "Nuns Bring Hope to Mississippi Delta Towns," New York Times, November 20, 2002. http://www.nytimes.com/2002/11/20/national/20NUNS.html
Sisters of Saint Joseph Federation
The Jonestown Learning Center and the Durocher Program:
Jonestown Family Center for Education and Wellness
Jonestown Newsletter - Fall 2009
Social Science Research Center: Success Stories: Jonestown
Mississippi and Rural Healthcare:
Healthcare in Mississippi website
The Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. "Eliminating Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Health Care: What are the Options?" 24 October 2008.
Mead, Holly, Lara Cartwright-Smith, Karen Jones, Christal Ramos, Kristy Woods, and Bruce Siegel. "Racial and Ethnic Disparities in U.S. Health Care: A Chartbook." The Commonwealth Fund. 13 March 2008.
Mississippi Delta Health Survey – October 2009
Nienaber, Georgianne. "The Campaign: The Audacity of Hope Did Not Die in Maine." Dick and Sharon's LA Progressive. 9 November 2009.
Rural Assistance Center: Mississippi Healthcare and Demographic Profile