"Good roads take people both ways," said
a Madison County resident, anticipating the completion of I-26
from Charleston, South Carolina, to the Tennessee Tri-Cities area
(Bristol-Kingsport-Johnson City). Starting in 1994, I began photographing,
interviewing, and collecting objects to document the cutting of
a nine-mile
stretch of I-26 through some of North Carolina’s most
spectacular vistas and some of the world’s oldest mountains.
During the surveying, mapping, core rock sampling, removal, and
construction phases,
I made over ten thousand negatives and hundreds of finished prints,
gathered more than two dozen oral histories, and collected boxes
of information and artifacts. I wondered what something so materially
"real" as the coming of I-26 might evoke through the
framing, detail, and
texture of photography. The result was not a pro- or anti-development
project, but one that voiced a range of emotion and opinion, often
from the same people (whether newcomers or natives).
When I arrived in Madison County, North Carolina, in 1973, I
possessed every stereotype possible about mountain people.
And I am certain that my new neighbors had equally suspect
notions about me and the small wave of people moving into their
midst. At first, I intended to produce the definitive
book of photographs on mountain culture. I had very preconceived
ideas of what that meant. I was taken with the romantic
idea
of
wizened faces, old women in doorways, men plowing into the
sunsets, hog butchering in the misty morning light.
That's what I thought the place was about. Those early photographs,
as
I look at them now, feel like clichés. Given time, my
increasing personal involvement, and the challenges of earning
a livelihood, I was able to overcome my preconceived notions
and try to understand the county's people for who they
were and are.
Like all newcomers, I was often greeted by, "You ain't
from around here?" And, people were right to ask, to question
my motivation. Why was I here? What right did I have to assume
that I could represent in my documentary work a culture I knew
little about? I was sometimes embarrassed that my photographs
offered no tangible benefits in a place that seemed to value
useful things that aided survival: firewood, bean seeds, a cut
of cloth. Then, as I grew more certain of my photography, I felt
that pictures offered memories full of historical and personal
detail, conveying the texture and feeling of the life around
me. Rather than seek the perfect photograph, the longer I lived
in Madison County, the more I became interested in recording
the process of events, and in documenting social and environmental
change.
To comprehend the costs of something as transformative as I-26
we must value intangible, but real concerns often dismissed as
"nostalgia" --
heartbreak for times past and beauty lost -- joined with an awareness
of environmental degradation, and anger over the direction in
which our society often moves. But how do we place a value on
a story? Or on a grave marker? How do we choose the narratives
that affect our future? What price do we pay for allowing our
memories, our environment, our places to be dismantled one step,
one mile, nine miles at a time?